The Multiplication Table Debate: Memorize or Understand? After Years of Parenting, Here's Why I Chose Both
'Two times two is four, two times three is six...' My daughter could recite the multiplication table like a song. But when I asked 'What does 2 × 3 mean?' she couldn't answer. That moment forced me to rethink everything about how we teach multiplication facts.
'Two times two is four, two times three is six, two times four is eight...' My daughter recited the multiplication table in a sing-song voice—she'd memorized it perfectly. Proud moment, right? Then I asked: 'What does 2 × 3 actually mean?' Silence. She had no idea. That discovery launched me into months of research, experimentation, and ultimately, a balanced approach that many parents overlook. Here's what I learned about the memorization vs. understanding debate.
The Two Camps: Memorize vs. Understand
Team Memorization
My parents' generation—and many traditional educators—advocate pure memorization. 'Recite until you know it cold. Then do it faster.' The reasoning:
- •Practical and efficient: Quick recall means faster problem-solving
- •Time-tested: Generations learned this way successfully
- •Foundation for higher math: Division, fractions, algebra all need automatic recall
- •Builds discipline: Memorization teaches persistence and routine
Team Understanding
Modern pedagogy often emphasizes conceptual understanding. 'Children must know WHY 2 × 3 = 6 before memorizing the fact.' The reasoning:
- •Flexible application: Understanding enables problem-solving in new contexts
- •Meaningful learning: Children retain what makes sense to them
- •Prevents rote learning: Memorization without understanding crumbles under pressure
- •Builds mathematical thinking: Concepts transfer; facts stay isolated
The debate frames memorization and understanding as opposites. But after teaching three children multiplication, I've concluded this framing is false—and harmful. The answer isn't choosing one camp. It's strategically combining both.
What Happens With Memorization Only
My daughter demonstrated the pure memorization problem perfectly.
She Could
- •Recite any multiplication fact instantly
- •Complete timed fact tests with high scores
- •Answer 'What is 7 × 8?' without hesitation
She Could Not
- •Explain what 7 × 8 means
- •Solve word problems requiring multiplication
- •Recognize when to use multiplication in real life
- •Recover if she forgot a fact (no strategy to derive it)
The word problem that exposed everything: 'A classroom has 6 rows of desks with 4 desks in each row. How many desks total?' She didn't recognize this as multiplication. She tried adding 6 + 4.
What Happens With Understanding Only
My second child went to a school emphasizing conceptual understanding. Great for meaning—but different problems emerged.
He Could
- •Explain that 4 × 5 means '4 groups of 5'
- •Draw arrays to represent multiplication
- •Solve word problems by identifying the operation needed
He Could Not
- •Answer basic facts quickly
- •Complete multi-step problems without losing track
- •Focus on higher-level thinking because basic facts consumed attention
- •Keep up with peers who had automatic recall
Every time he needed 7 × 6, he'd count: '7, 14, 21, 28, 35, 42.' Correct—but slow. On complex problems, this counting consumed so much mental energy that he'd lose track of what he was actually solving.
Why BOTH Matter: The Cognitive Science
Research on working memory explains why both approaches are necessary.
Working Memory Is Limited
We can only hold a few items in active thought at once. If basic multiplication consumes that space, no capacity remains for higher-level reasoning.
Automatic Recall Frees Mental Resources
When 7 × 8 = 56 is automatic, working memory is available for the complex problem using that fact. When 7 × 8 requires counting, working memory is consumed by the basic operation.
But Understanding Provides Recovery Strategies
If a memorized fact is forgotten under pressure, understanding provides paths to recover: 'I forgot 7 × 8, but I know 7 × 7 = 49, so 7 × 8 must be 49 + 7 = 56.' Without understanding, forgetting is catastrophic.
| Aspect | Memorization Provides | Understanding Provides |
|---|---|---|
| Speed | Instant recall | Derivation strategies (slower) |
| Reliability | Works when facts are retained | Recovery when facts are forgotten |
| Application | Fast computation | Knowing when to apply which operation |
| Flexibility | Fixed facts only | Adaptation to new problems |
| Higher math | Efficient foundations | Conceptual building blocks |
The Balanced Approach: How I Teach Now
After three children, here's the method that works.
Phase 1: Build Understanding First
Before any memorization, ensure the child understands multiplication conceptually.
- •Repeated addition: 3 × 4 means 4 + 4 + 4
- •Groups of objects: 3 groups with 4 items each
- •Arrays: 3 rows and 4 columns
- •Real-world contexts: 3 boxes of 4 donuts
Don't rush this phase. A child who truly understands will say things like: 'Oh, so 5 × 3 is just 3 added five times!' When they make connections independently, understanding is solid.
Phase 2: Build Fluency Strategically
Once understanding exists, build toward automatic recall—but strategically, not through brute repetition.
Start with easy wins:
- •× 1 facts (anything times 1 is itself)
- •× 2 facts (doubles—often already known)
- •× 10 facts (add a zero)
- •× 5 facts (count by 5s)
Then build on known facts:
- •× 4 = double the × 2 fact
- •× 3 = × 2 + one more group
- •× 9 = × 10 - one group
Tackle toughest facts last:
- •6 × 7, 6 × 8, 7 × 8 need the most practice
- •Use stories, rhymes, or personal mnemonics
Phase 3: Practice for Automaticity
Understanding provides meaning; strategic learning reduces the load. But automatic recall requires practice—spaced, varied, and pressure-free.
- •Daily brief practice: 5-10 minutes of facts
- •Mixed practice: Don't drill one fact family at a time—mix them
- •Games over drills: Card games, apps, competitions
- •Low pressure: Time pressure increases anxiety; start untimed
The goal of Phase 3 isn't speed initially—it's accuracy and confidence. Speed develops naturally as accuracy becomes consistent. Pushing speed before accuracy creates anxious, error-prone children.
Practical Activities That Combine Both
Activity: Multiplication Stories
Instead of 'What is 4 × 6?' ask 'There are 4 spider legs on each side. How many total?' This tests both the fact AND whether the child recognizes multiplication contexts.
Activity: Fact Derivation Practice
Occasionally ask: 'If you forgot 7 × 6, how could you figure it out?' This reinforces that facts can be derived, not just recalled. Acceptable answers: '7 × 5 + 7' or '6 × 6 + 6' or 'count by 7s six times.'
Activity: Array Building
Give a fact like 5 × 4 and have the child build it with objects, draw it, then state the answer. This connects concrete understanding with abstract symbols.
Activity: Speed Challenges (Once Ready)
After accuracy is solid, timed challenges build automaticity. But always ensure the child enjoys it—pressure should feel like a fun challenge, not stress.
How Long Should This Take?
Parents often ask: 'When should my child know all multiplication facts automatically?'
Realistic Timeline
- •End of 2nd grade: Conceptual understanding of multiplication
- •End of 3rd grade: Fluency with easier facts (×1, ×2, ×5, ×10)
- •End of 4th grade: Near-automatic recall of all facts
- •5th grade and beyond: Complete automaticity, facts used without conscious thought
Children develop at different rates. Some achieve automaticity faster; others need more time. The critical factor is consistent, low-pressure practice—not cramming.
What I'd Tell My Past Self
Looking back at my first child (pure memorization) and second child (pure understanding), here's what I wish I'd known:
- •The debate is false: It's not memorize OR understand—it's understand THEN memorize
- •Order matters: Understanding first creates meaningful memorization
- •Strategies reduce load: Learning patterns (×4 is double ×2) means fewer facts to memorize
- •Automaticity is non-negotiable: Eventually, facts must be instant for higher math success
- •Pressure backfires: Anxiety blocks recall—keep practice low-stakes and fun
My third child learned multiplication with the balanced approach. She understands what multiplication means, recalls facts automatically, and can derive forgotten facts. Most importantly—she actually enjoys math. That's the outcome I wish for every child.
Build multiplication mastery the right way—understanding AND fluency. Sorokid's program develops conceptual foundations first, then builds automatic recall through engaging practice.
Start Balanced Learning