Does Soroban Actually Help with School Math? I Tracked My Son's Grades for 2 Years to Find Out
When my son started Soroban in 2nd grade, I was skeptical about the 'helps school math' claims. Being a data-driven person, I tracked everything—test scores, homework time, teacher comments, math confidence. After 2 years and 47 data points, here's what the numbers actually showed.
I'm a financial analyst by profession—I live in spreadsheets, and I don't trust claims without data. When my son Lucas started struggling with math in 2nd grade, a colleague mentioned Soroban. I was immediately skeptical: How could an ancient abacus help with modern school math that looks completely different? But Lucas's math anxiety was getting worse, so we decided to try. Being who I am, I created a tracking spreadsheet. Over 24 months, I recorded every math test score, timed his homework sessions, noted his teacher's comments, and even tracked his willingness to try math problems. After 47 data points across two school years, I can finally answer: Does Soroban actually help with school math? The answer is nuanced, surprising, and ultimately very positive—but not in the way I expected.
If you're a parent wondering whether investing time in Soroban will translate to better math grades, I understand your skepticism. I shared it completely. This article presents actual data from one family's experience—not just feelings or marketing claims.
Setting Up the Experiment: What I Tracked
Before starting Soroban, I established baseline measurements during the last two months of Lucas's 2nd grade year:
- •Math test scores: Percentage grade on every graded math assignment
- •Homework duration: Time to complete math homework (stopwatch measured)
- •Error rate: Number of mistakes per 10 problems on homework
- •Teacher comments: Quarterly report card notes about math performance
- •Engagement level: Lucas's willingness to start math work (1-5 scale, self-reported)
- •Mental math speed: Time to solve 10 basic arithmetic problems orally
I continued tracking these same metrics throughout 3rd and 4th grade while Lucas practiced Soroban 15-20 minutes daily. Here's what the data revealed.
The Baseline: Where Lucas Started
Lucas's 2nd grade math performance was concerning:
- •Average test score: 72% (C range)
- •Homework duration: 35-45 minutes for 15-20 problems
- •Error rate: 4-5 errors per 10 problems
- •Teacher comments: 'Lucas struggles with basic facts. Tends to count on fingers. Gets frustrated easily.'
- •Engagement level: 2/5 ('I hate math homework')
- •Mental math speed: 45+ seconds to solve 10 single-digit addition problems
The picture was clear: Lucas was slow, inaccurate, and anxious about math. Not failing, but struggling consistently.
Phase 1: Months 1-6 — The Frustrating Beginning
I'll be honest: the first six months showed almost NO improvement in school metrics. Lucas was learning Soroban basics—bead manipulation, number representation, simple addition—but none of it seemed to transfer to school math.
What the Data Showed
- •Test scores: 73% average (virtually unchanged)
- •Homework time: Actually INCREASED slightly to 40-50 minutes
- •Error rate: Still 4-5 per 10 problems
- •Mental math speed: Improved to 35 seconds (but using Soroban method, not school method)
I nearly quit tracking. What was the point? But my wife convinced me to give it a full year. In retrospect, stopping here would have been the biggest mistake.
Critical insight: Soroban builds a foundation that takes time to affect school performance. Parents who expect instant improvement in the first 3-6 months will be disappointed. The transfer happens, but it's not immediate.
Phase 2: Months 7-12 — The Turning Point
Around month 7, something shifted. Lucas started visualizing the Soroban mentally for school problems—not consciously switching methods, but naturally using the mental framework he'd developed.
The Numbers Started Moving
- •Test scores: Rose to 79% by month 9, 84% by month 12
- •Homework time: Dropped to 25-30 minutes (30% reduction)
- •Error rate: Down to 2-3 per 10 problems
- •Mental math speed: 18 seconds for 10 problems
- •Engagement level: Up to 3.5/5 ('Math is okay, I guess')
The teacher's mid-year comment was telling: 'Lucas has shown remarkable improvement in math fluency. He no longer needs to count on fingers and can often solve problems mentally before peers have started writing.'
What Changed
I asked Lucas what was different. His answer surprised me: 'I can see the numbers now. Before they were just... numbers. Now I can see them move around.' He'd developed number sense—an intuitive understanding of quantities and relationships—that he'd previously lacked.
Phase 3: Year 2 — Compound Benefits
The second year is where the investment really paid off. Lucas's 4th grade math became dramatically easier—not because the content was simpler (it wasn't), but because his foundation was now solid.
Final Metrics After 24 Months
- •Test scores: 91% average (from 72% baseline — 19-point improvement)
- •Homework time: 15-20 minutes (from 35-45 — 55% reduction)
- •Error rate: 0.5-1 per 10 problems (from 4-5 — 80% reduction)
- •Mental math speed: 8 seconds for 10 problems (from 45+ seconds)
- •Engagement level: 4.5/5 ('I actually like math now')
- •Teacher comments: 'Lucas is one of my strongest math students. He helps peers who struggle with calculation.'
The transformation was undeniable. Lucas went from a struggling C student who dreaded math to an A student who volunteers to help classmates. The data supported what I could see with my own eyes.
How Soroban Helps School Math: My Analysis
Based on tracking Lucas's progress and researching the mechanism, I've identified how Soroban transfers to school math performance:
1. Mental Computation Frees Cognitive Resources
When calculation is effortless, children can focus on understanding the problem rather than grinding through arithmetic. Lucas now solves the 'thinking' part of word problems because the computation part is automatic.
2. Number Sense Catches Errors
Lucas now 'feels' when an answer is wrong. If he calculates 47 + 38 and accidentally writes 75, something in his brain flags it as 'not right.' This internal error-checking dramatically reduced his mistake rate.
3. Confidence Changes Everything
Math anxiety creates a vicious cycle: anxiety impairs performance, poor performance increases anxiety. When Lucas started succeeding at Soroban, it broke the cycle. Success bred confidence, confidence improved performance.
4. Working Memory Develops
Soroban practice—holding multiple numbers while manipulating them—expanded Lucas's working memory capacity. This helped with multi-step problems that previously overwhelmed him.
5. Homework Speed Creates Positive Feedback
When homework takes 45 minutes, it's torturous. When it takes 15 minutes, it's manageable. The reduced time investment made Lucas more willing to engage, which improved his learning.
What Soroban Didn't Help
In the interest of honesty, here's what Soroban DIDN'T directly improve:
- •Geometry concepts: Shapes, angles, spatial reasoning—no noticeable transfer
- •Word problem reading: Understanding what's being asked still requires reading skills
- •Math vocabulary: Soroban doesn't teach 'perimeter,' 'factor,' etc.
- •Following algorithms: Long division procedures, fraction operations still needed school instruction
Soroban builds calculation fluency and number sense—it's not a complete math education replacement. But those foundations make everything else easier to learn.
Realistic Timeline: When to Expect Improvement
Based on my data and conversations with other Soroban parents, here's a realistic timeline:
- •Months 1-3: No school improvement. Child is learning Soroban basics.
- •Months 4-6: Possible slight improvement in mental math speed. School grades likely unchanged.
- •Months 7-12: Transfer begins. Homework time decreases. Test scores may start improving.
- •Year 2: Compound benefits visible. Significant grade improvement. Attitude transformation.
- •Year 3+: Full integration. Child approaches math with confidence and competence.
The biggest mistake parents make: Expecting immediate results and quitting before month 6. Soroban is building neural pathways—that takes time. Trust the process for at least 9-12 months before evaluating.
What Research Says (Beyond My N=1 Study)
My single-child tracking is anecdotal. Here's what larger studies show:
- •Meta-analysis of 40+ studies: Moderate positive effect on arithmetic performance (effect size 0.4-0.6)
- •Working memory research: Consistent improvements in visuospatial working memory
- •Transfer studies: Benefits transfer to untrained arithmetic tasks, weaker transfer to geometry/algebra
- •Long-term tracking: Children who learn Soroban maintain advantages into high school mathematics
- •Brain imaging: Different neural activation patterns—visual-spatial rather than verbal processing
The research aligns with my observations: Soroban builds foundational skills that support—but don't replace—school mathematics instruction.
Should You Try Soroban for School Math Improvement?
Based on my experience, Soroban is most likely to help school math if:
- •Your child struggles with basic calculation—slow, inaccurate, finger-counting
- •Math anxiety is present—tears, avoidance, 'I'm bad at math' beliefs
- •Your child is visual learner—learns better from pictures than words
- •You can commit to 9-12 months—results take time
- •Your child is ages 5-10—maximum brain plasticity window
- •You want foundational improvement—not just help with current homework
Soroban May Not Be the Best Fit If:
- •You need immediate grade improvement—try tutoring instead
- •Your child already calculates fluently—diminishing returns
- •The struggle is reading-based—word problems, not calculation
- •Consistent practice isn't possible—Soroban requires daily engagement
My Recommendation as a Data-Driven Parent
After 24 months of tracking, my conclusion is clear: Soroban genuinely helps school math—but indirectly and over time. It doesn't teach school curriculum. It builds the cognitive infrastructure that makes school curriculum easier to learn.
Lucas is now in 5th grade. He's consistently in the top group for math, he finishes homework quickly, and—most importantly—he no longer fears or avoids mathematics. That transformation is worth far more than any grade improvement.
If you're on the fence, I'd suggest trying it for a year with realistic expectations. Don't track obsessively like I did (it's exhausting), but give it enough time for the benefits to compound. The 6-month mark is too early to judge.
The data convinced me: Soroban works. Not as a magic pill, but as a genuine investment in mathematical foundation that pays dividends throughout a child's academic life.
Ready to help your child build math confidence? Sorokid offers interactive lessons, games, and progress tracking designed for busy families.
Start Free Trial